onlyfire Grill Part vs Charbroil 1258466R06 Grill Part
When a grill part fails, you want a replacement that fits right and ships fast without draining your wallet. The onlyfire part is built for gas setups and comes in at $8.54, making it one of the more affordable options in this category with over 4,500 buyer reviews behind it. The Charbroil 1258466R06 is a stainless steel part designed for charcoal grills, priced at $23.00 with a slightly higher 4.6 rating across 4,100 reviews. These two parts serve different fuel types entirely, so the right pick comes down to what kind of grill you are repairing. Knowing that upfront saves a return trip.
Quick winner
The onlyfire part wins on price for gas grill owners, while the Charbroil 1258466R06 is the clear pick for anyone repairing a Charbroil charcoal grill.
Key differences, measured
- The onlyfire Grill Part is 63% cheaper ($8.54 vs $23.00).
- The onlyfire Grill Part is 1.7 lb heavier (2.4 lb vs 0.7 lb).
Side-by-side specs
| Spec | onlyfire Grill Part | Charbroil 1258466R06 Grill Part |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $8.54 | $23.00 |
| Rating | ||
| Fuel | Gas | Charcoal |
| Weight | 2.4 lb | 0.7 lb |
The two contenders
onlyfire Grill Part
The onlyfire grill part is rated for gas fuel and measures 3.15 x 2.17 x 3.1 inches, making it a compact replacement suited to gas grill connections. At $8.54 it is significantly cheaper than most competing parts in this segment, and its 4,500-plus reviews show strong repeat buy confidence. The 4.5-star rating is solid for a value-priced replacement part. At 2.4 lb it is a bit heavier than the Charbroil counterpart, which may reflect denser construction for its size.
Buy this if: ['Gas grill owners looking for a budget-friendly replacement part under $10.', 'Buyers who want a high-volume, well-reviewed part for a gas connection repair.', 'Grillers who need a compact part at 3.15 x 2.17 x 3.1 inches for a snug fit in a gas grill assembly.']
Check price on AmazonCharbroil 1258466R06 Grill Part
The Charbroil 1258466R06 is a stainless steel grill part built specifically for charcoal grill applications. It carries a 4.6-star rating from over 4,100 reviewers, making it one of the more trusted Charbroil replacement parts on the market. At $23.00 it costs nearly three times as much as the onlyfire option, though the stainless steel construction justifies some of that premium for durability in direct-heat environments. Weighing just 0.7 lb, it is a lightweight component that installs without adding bulk.
Buy this if: ['Charbroil charcoal grill owners who need an OEM-matched stainless steel replacement part.', 'Buyers who prioritize a slightly higher rating and a major brand name for peace of mind on a charcoal setup.', 'Anyone replacing a lightweight component on a Charbroil charcoal grill and willing to spend $23.00 for stainless steel quality.']
Check price on AmazonFrequently asked questions
Are these two parts interchangeable?
No. The onlyfire part is rated for gas fuel while the Charbroil 1258466R06 is designed for charcoal grill use. Using a part intended for the wrong fuel type and grill design can result in a poor fit or improper function. Always match the replacement part to your grill's fuel type and model.
Which part has more buyer reviews?
The onlyfire part edges ahead with over 4,500 reviews compared to roughly 4,100 for the Charbroil 1258466R06. Both counts are large enough to represent reliable aggregate feedback. The Charbroil part scores a slightly higher 4.6 stars versus the onlyfire's 4.5 stars.
Is the price difference worth it for the Charbroil part?
If you own a Charbroil charcoal grill, the 1258466R06 at $23.00 offers stainless steel construction and brand-matched fitment that a generic part cannot guarantee. For gas grill owners, the onlyfire at $8.54 is a better value. The premium on the Charbroil part is primarily justified by material quality and model compatibility.
Which part is lighter and easier to install?
The Charbroil 1258466R06 is lighter at 0.7 lb compared to the onlyfire at 2.4 lb. A lighter part can be easier to handle during installation, particularly in tight spaces on a charcoal grill. The onlyfire's greater weight is consistent with the denser hardware typical of gas-side fittings.